White Suburbanites Vote Republican, Stun Nation
(Revised on 26 January)
Even though I was born in Boston, I spent my early years in the town of North Andover, in northeastern Massachusett’s Essex County. Full of greenery, winding roads, old cottages and a Congregationalist church, it is also home to not a few ostentatious houses and parking spaces. A quasi-rural part of Greater Boston, North Andover is classic New England exurbia. Pickup trucks were a regular part of the landscape. Although my family might have struck outsiders as classic Bay Staters during the Dukakis years—Greek-American liberals with a Volvo (and Dad’s a professor to boot)—pickup trucks were a regular part of my landscape. Thinking back to North Andover today, I’m not at all surprised that 64% of its voters supported Scott Brown. My big question isn’t why they voted for Brown, but why North Andover doesn’t follow the rest of America’s exurbs and vote red more often.
If the Brown election was exceptional, it was only because Martha Coakley fashioned a uniquely unlikeable self-image. As Cheneyesque Brown’s views on torture may be, Coakley’s rudeness was much more alienating to the Massachusetts electorate. Brown’s better-fashioned image made it easy to overlook the venality of his platform, and American voters have often favored persona over policy. Brown’s anti-tax message was interpreted by Bay Staters as representing “fiscal responsibility”—what better way to reduce the deficit than by not spending the money to reduce it and blocking efforts to reduce the cost of Medicare? This inability to do subtraction is a well-entrenched aspect of American political economy. People in Massachusetts, it turns out, are Real AmericansTM after all.
Thus we have the panic amongst the Democrats about losing “Middle America.” As noted above, North Andover certainly looks Middle American enough. Did I forget to mention that North Andover’s almost 95% white? As Reagan sppechwriter Peggy Noonan opined observed of Brown, “He’s a regular guy, looks like an American.”
Now we’ve hit something. Although this doesn’t explain why North Andover usually votes blue, demography might be part of the reason for the Republican turn in less urbanized areas in Massachusetts—and for the exurbs’ conservatism nationwide. The New Republic’s Thomas B. Edsall quotes Robert Powell, a sociologist (appropriately enough) at Harvard: “New evidence from the US suggests that in ethnically diverse neighborhoods residents of all races tend to ‘hunker down.’” This is a familiar story to any urban geographer and historian—Chicago is the classic example. Edsall argues that white “hunkering down” is responsible for the emergence of the Tea Party movement as a national force. “The demographic transformation of the country and the birth of multicultural America have made this group extremely status anxious—an anxiety that the recession obviously heightens.” Even if we don’t accept Edsall’s argument that the anti-health care backlash is rooted in the fear of a transfer of wealth and benefits from white to non-white communities, the geographical implications of the Massachusetts vote are obvious: Massachusetts already pays for its own health care—why should it pay for other states’?
Even when people “hunker down” in a city, though, urban density makes juxtapositions inevitable. Obviously there’s tension (which sometimes erupts), but proximity also has a way of breaking down barriers between groups. In a city, a conversation between a Greek-American, a Uyghur-American, and a Cambodian-American is completely possible (as a matter of fact, it happened in Cambridge last summer). Cosmopolitanism is more likely in the polis.
When we deal with statewide and nationwide politics, however, different patterns emerge. It’s hard to breach ethnic barriers when communities are separated by the interstates and where random encounters are limited to the mall and supermarket. As the de facto segregation of the northern urban areas demonstrates, this has been an issue for over a half-century. The internet doesn’t make things any better—as Cass Sunstein argues in Republic.com 2.0, hunkering down is worse on the internet than anywhere else.
Older, white voters were among Brown’s strongest supporters (pdf). The country is changing into something unfamiliar, and they are discomforted by it. This is not necessarily active racism, , but rather a vague sense that things should continue to be as they are. Of course Massachusetts has a strong history of active racism: the last person who held “the people’s seat” was pelted with tomatoes by his constituents over school busing, in very urban Boston no less. Such racial conflicts led to the spatial segregation we have today. So it takes more than an urban zip code to be a cosmopolitan—it requires stepping out of one’s perceptual shell in order to view to world in a broader way.
Brown’s victory does nothing to change the broad demographic trends that are reshaping the country. Whites will no longer be an ethnic majority, and almost a fifth of our citizens will be foreign-born. It is our generation’s task to redefine Middle America as the meeting place between peoples, not the provenance of one race and history. Not only does our nation have great potential for cosmopolitanism, it has great need for it. If Americans decide to hunker down, whatever challenges facing the nation as a whole will go unrecognized, and whatever satisfaction that comes from crouching with our own kind will be false comfort at best.
the attachments to this post:
The_Gerry-Mander_Edit
You know, I gotta tell you, I genuinely savor this website and the informative insight. I find it to be refreshing and very enlightening. I wish there were more blogs like it. Anyway, I finally decided to write a comment on White Suburbanites Vote Republican, Stun Nation | Diskord – I just wanna tell you that you did a sweet job on this. Cheers dude!
First up, great post! I’ve got a small question bothering me, I really like the theme of your blog and tried to download the same design on my WP site. Anyhow, there is some kind of strange php error in the footer. Do you have any tips, which settings are you using? Please PM me on Twitter @ThaiLivin or via e-mail.
Hi – I would like to say thanks for an interesting post about a subject I have had an interest in for a long time now. I have been lurking and reading the posts avidly so just wanted to express my gratitude for providing me with some very good reading material. I look forward to more, and taking a more active part in the discussions here, whilst learning too!!
I loved reading such a good article. Such entertaining writing is rare these days. Informed comment like this has to be applauded. I’ll certainly be looking in on this blog again in the near future!
Outsourcing site that has more than just the normal government projects listed. Looks good.
I am going to visit again for the next different interesting topic..
Heard about this site from my friend. He pointed me here and told me I’d find what I need. He was right! I got all the questions I had, answered. Didn’t even take long to find it. Love the fact that you made it so easy for people like me. More power
I was looking for catering related tips this was good
It seems that you’ve put a great amount of effort into your article and I want to see a lot more of these on the Internet these days. I really got a kick out of your post. I do not have a bunch to to say in reply, I only wanted to register to say remarkable work.
Hi There, I just spent a little time reading through your posts, which I found entirely by mistake whilst researching one of my projects. Please continue to write more because it’s unusual that someone has something interesting to say about this. Will be waiting for more!
excellent post.
I was pleased to read this article, keep up the good work.
I’m a huge fan of this website and I read it regularly. Keep up the excellent work!
good day. Awesome editorial. Saved and will come back again soon. thankyou
I appreciate you for this specific useful post! Furthermore have a web site and i’m thinking, how can i obtain like great theme like yours?
Thankyou, that is extremely good information, cheers.
My friend referred me to your blog, so I thought I’d check it out. Very interesting insights, will be back for more!
Nice looking blog you have here. The theme is awesome, great color combination.
appreciated lots, I am obliged to announce that your website is fantastic!
There is evidently a lot for me to learn outside of my books. Thanks for the wonderful read,
I must say, I enjoy reading this website. Maybe you could tell me how I can go about keeping up to date with it? I feel I should let you know I found this site through Yahoo.
You can subscribe to our RSS feed on the main page. There are also options for live bookmarks on the bottom of each article. They are compatible with every system: yahoo etc
Bookmarked your site. Thank you for sharing. Definitely worth the time away from my workload.
This is a great web blog. we visit here frequently and we get always valuable updates, regards!
Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbour were preparing to do some research about that. We got a good book on that matter from our local library and most books where not as influensive as your information.
Hi,Excellent blogging dude! i am Tired of using RSS feeds and do you use twitter?so i can follow you there:D.
PS:Have you thought about putting video to the blog posts to keep the visitors more enjoyed?I think it works., Reed Mayle
You can follow us on http://twitter.com/diskordchicago
Thanks for reading!
Dear Web site owner. My partner and i actually enjoy this post and the internet site all in all! Your piece of writing is really plainly composed as well as simply understandable. Your current Blog design is awesome as well! Would be awesome to know where I are able obtain it. Please maintain up the very good job. We all require far more such website owners like you on the net and much fewer spammers. Fantastic mate!
I like your website plain and simple. Keep up the good work and I will keep reading you.
TYVM, wonderful job! This was what I needed to know.